In a historic yet contentious development, Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost of Chicago has been elected as Pope Leo XIV, marking the first time an American has ascended to the papacy.
However, his past social media activity, particularly his critiques of former President Donald Trump’s policies, has sparked concern among conservative circles.
Prior to his election, Prevost maintained an active presence on social media platform X (formerly Twitter), where he frequently shared posts critical of the Trump administration’s immigration policies.
He reposted articles opposing the separation of migrant families and the refugee ban, and expressed support for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. In one instance, he shared an op-ed challenging Vice President J.D. Vance’s interpretation of Christian love, suggesting that prioritizing Americans over others contradicts Christian teachings.
These posts have led to accusations from some conservative commentators that Pope Leo XIV supports open borders and aligns with progressive ideologies. The Gateway Pundit reported that he previously took aim at Vice President Vance for defending American sovereignty, raising concerns about the Pope’s stance on national security and immigration enforcement.
Despite these criticisms, it’s noteworthy that Pope Leo XIV has a history of participating in Republican primaries, having voted in 2012, 2014, and 2016. This suggests a complex political background that doesn’t neatly align with a single ideology.
In his first public address as Pope, Leo XIV emphasized themes of peace, unity, and compassion. He spoke in multiple languages, including Spanish, reflecting his years of missionary work in Peru. He also paid tribute to his predecessor, Pope Francis, and called for a Church rooted in inclusivity and mission.
While some conservative figures have expressed apprehension about Pope Leo XIV’s past statements, others have adopted a more measured approach. Former President Trump extended his congratulations, stating, “To have the pope from the United States of America, that’s a great honor”.
The election of Pope Leo XIV comes at a time when the Catholic Church continues to navigate complex social and political issues. His past social media activity suggests a commitment to certain progressive causes, but his broader political history indicates a more nuanced perspective. As the Church’s new leader, how he balances these viewpoints will be closely watched by Catholics around the world.
It’s essential for the faithful to remain vigilant and discerning, ensuring that the Church’s teachings remain grounded in Scripture and tradition. While compassion and care for the marginalized are central to the Christian faith, they must be balanced with prudence and respect for national sovereignty.
As Pope Leo XIV begins his papacy, many will be praying for wisdom and guidance, hoping that he leads the Church with clarity, conviction, and fidelity to its foundational truths.
Ella Ford