New York Pays $225K to End Legal Battle With Christian Photographer Over Same-Sex Weddings
In a landmark settlement that underscores the ongoing tension between religious liberty and state anti-discrimination laws, New York has agreed to pay $225,000 to a Christian photographer who declined to provide services for same-sex weddings due to her religious convictions. The decision marks a significant victory for advocates of religious freedom in the United States.
The case centered on Emilee Carpenter, a professional photographer from New York who faced legal threats under the state’s anti-discrimination statute. The law prohibits businesses open to the public from refusing service based on sexual orientation. Carpenter, citing her deeply held Christian beliefs about marriage, declined to photograph same-sex weddings, arguing that doing so would compel her to violate her faith.
Rather than compromise her convictions, Carpenter sought legal protection, contending that the state’s enforcement of its law infringed upon her First Amendment rights. With the help of Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), a legal organization dedicated to protecting religious liberty, Carpenter challenged the law in court.
For years, her case wove through the judicial system, reflecting broader national debates over where the line between anti-discrimination laws and religious freedom should be drawn. Opponents of Carpenter’s stance argued that her refusal constituted unlawful discrimination, while supporters maintained that forcing her to use her artistic skills to celebrate something contrary to her faith was government overreach.
In July 2025, New York agreed to end the protracted battle by signing a consent decree and paying Carpenter $225,000 in legal fees and damages. According to the agreement, Carpenter will no longer face penalties for declining to photograph same-sex weddings, and the state acknowledged her right to operate her business consistent with her religious convictions.
ADF celebrated the settlement as a resounding win for free speech and religious freedom. “The government should never force artists to create messages that violate their core beliefs,” said ADF Senior Counsel Jonathan Scruggs. “This settlement affirms that the First Amendment protects individuals from being coerced into speech they do not support.”
The consent decree, filed in federal court, effectively shields Carpenter from future enforcement of the law in similar circumstances. While the state did not admit wrongdoing, the payout and legal protections granted to Carpenter send a clear message about the limits of state power in compelling speech.
This case is part of a growing body of legal decisions affirming the rights of Christian business owners. In 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of Colorado web designer Lorie Smith in 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis, holding that the state could not force her to create custom wedding websites for same-sex couples. That decision set a strong precedent for cases like Carpenter’s, signaling judicial recognition of artistic expression as protected speech under the First Amendment.
For many Christians, this settlement is more than a legal victory—it is a cultural milestone in the battle to preserve religious freedom in an increasingly secular society. The case highlights the fundamental question: Should the state have the power to dictate the messages that artists must create, even when doing so violates their conscience?
Critics of the settlement, however, argue that such outcomes open the door to discrimination under the guise of religious liberty. They warn that these decisions could undermine civil rights protections for LGBTQ individuals. Supporters counter that true tolerance requires respecting differing beliefs, especially in matters of faith and personal conscience.
The Carpenter settlement illustrates that the struggle between religious freedom and government mandates is far from over. As similar cases arise nationwide, courts will continue to navigate these constitutional crossroads. For now, Carpenter’s victory stands as a beacon of hope for Christian professionals seeking to live out their faith without fear of state-imposed penalties.
✅ Keywords (10)
-
Emilee Carpenter
-
Religious freedom
-
Christian photographer
-
Same-sex marriage law
-
First Amendment rights
-
Alliance Defending Freedom
-
Anti-discrimination law
-
New York settlement
-
Free speech case
-
Faith-based business rights