2024 Election
American Mother, Daughter Taken Hostage In Israel Released As First Photo Of Them Freed Emerges — And Biden Pledges Support
An American mother and daughter who were taken hostage when Hamas stormed the kibbutz they were visiting earlier this month have been released, officials said Friday.
Judith Raanan and her 17-year-old daughter, Natalie, were both let go from Hamas custody in Gaza and were said to be en route to a military base in central Israel to reunite with their family, the office of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed on X.
A photograph later showed the mother and daughter being escorted through the night by what appeared to be military officials.
Prior to Netanyahu’s statement, Hamas officials said that they released the two women following Qatar’s intervention in negotiation efforts.

Judith Raanan and her 17-year-old daughter Natalie are seen for the first time since being released.
“In response to Qatari efforts, Al-Qassam Brigades released two American citizens (a mother and her daughter) for humanitarian reasons, and to prove to the American people and the world that the claims made by Biden and his fascist administration are false and baseless,” the announcement read, according to the Times of Israel.

Judith Raanan and her 18-year-old daughter, Natalie, are among those who were taken hostage by Hamas.
The two victims were transferred from Gaza to the Israeli border by the Red Cross, the officials added.
They were released due to Judith’s declining health, the Times of Israel reported.
President Biden spoke with the Raanans after their release, he announced on X.

Judith Raanan was en route to meet her family.
“I just spoke with the two Americans released today after being held hostage by Hamas. I let them know that their government will fully support them as they recover and heal,” he said.

Natalie Raanan with her grandmother, whose 85th birthday they had traveled to Israel to celebrate.
“Jill and I will continue holding close in our hearts all the families of unaccounted for Americans.”
In a statement earlier in the day, the commander in chief said, “Our fellow citizens have endured a terrible ordeal these past 14 days, and I am overjoyed that they will soon be reunited with their family, who has been wracked with fear.”

The two victims were transferred from Gaza to the Israeli border by the Red Cross, the officials added.
“I thank the government of Qatar and the government of Israel for their partnership in this work,” he added. “And, as I told those families when I spoke with them last week — we will not stop until we get their loved ones home. As president, I have no higher priority than the safety of Americans held hostage around the world.”

President Biden speaks to Judith and Natalie Raanan after their release.
Judith and Natalie, of Evanston, Ill., were taken hostage when Hamas stormed Kibbutz Nahal Oz 13 days ago, it was previously reported.
Their release is “hopefully the start of more to come,” a diplomatic source told CNN.
The same source also confirmed that there were no exchanges involved in the release, the outlet noted.

Rachel Goldberg, the US-Israeli mother of Hersh Goldberg Polin, who was taken hostage by Hamas militants into the Gaza Strip.
“The families’ headquarters welcomes the release of hostages from Hamas captivity,” the Hostages and Missing Families Forum — which represents the relatives of the Hamas hostages — said in a statement sent to CNN.
“The continued holding of hostages is a war crime. Hundreds of families await the assistance of leaders of Arab states after Hamas’ actions shocked the entire world,” the write-up continued.
“Hamas committed war crimes. Many leaders in Arab states have tremendous influence over its leaders and must act to immediately release all the hostages and missing held in Gaza.”
Uri Raanan, Natalie’s father and Judith’s ex-husband, could not immediately be reached by The Post for a comment.
Since his daughter and former spouse went missing, Uri Raanan, who also lives in Illinois, has maintained a Facebook page covered in pleas for the pair’s release.
He also opened a GoFundMe for the effort, which stopped accepting donations sometime late Thursday or early Friday.
The Raanans were enjoying a “really special” trip to Israel to celebrate the 85th birthday of Judith’s monther and observe the Jewish holiday season when the Hamas war started, their rabbi, Meir Hecht, told the outlet.
The mother and daughter’s family members have also been informed, the report added.
“This is a huge sigh of relief,” relative Martin Fletcher, an NBC correspondent who once covered the Middle East and was the network’s Tel Aviv bureau chief, told MSNBC. “It’s a miracle.”
Armed terrorists from Hamas took at least 203 people — including young children and the elderly — captive and killed hundreds more during the early-morning launch of Operation Al-Aqsa Flood on Oct. 7.
The deadly raid — which started when Hamas stormed through the border crossing between southern Israel and the Gaza Strip and launched thousands of rockets in the space of just a couple hours — kicked off the Israel-Hamas war that has since killed over 1,400 Israelis.
Since the start of the conflict, Israeli officials have vowed to wipe out Hamas while also working to rescue the hostages, many of whom were believed to be held in the terror group’s tunnel system underneath Gaza.
At one point, Hamas suggested that the hostages could be exchanged for the approximately 6,000 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons.
The group also stated that over 20 hostages had been killed by Israeli airstrikes, but did not provide further details.
Israel subsequently announced that its formidable blockade of the Strip would not end until all the hostages were released.
Hopeful viewers, however, should be careful not to trust Hamas’ “humanitarian” angle on releasing the Raanans, former FBI agent and hostage team expert Christopher O’Leary told The Post.
“They are doing this for calculated reasons,” O’Leary insisted, noting that “Hamas does not have a humanitarian bone in their body.”
“This was not a goodwill or good faith gesture … they are playing a long game with the hostages,” he added.
“They may be doing it to build some credibility in negotiations, [because] right now they do not seem like a legitimate negotiator.
“It also could be a counternarrative to what Biden put out yesterday, going directly after Hamas and categorizing them as a terrorist organization.”
“Hamas is the quintessential terrorist organization,” O’Leary concluded.
On Oct. 20 — nearly two weeks after the initial Hamas attack — the Israel Defense Forces also confirmed that more than 20 of the hostages were under the age of 18, with another 10 to 20 over age 60, the Wall Street Journal reported.
At the time, the IDF also said it had reason to believe that the majority of the hostages were still alive — though it was still scanning the Gaza border for bodies of missing Israelis, spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari said at a press conference, per the Times of Israel.
Several hostages were believed to have been taken from the attack on the Tribe of Nova music festival in the southern Negev, where 260 people were gunned down when Hamas stormed the outdoor concert area.
One of the festival captives, Mia Shem, appeared alive in a brief clip on Oct. 16 and detailed a harrowing three-hour surgery in Gaza before begging for her release.
“They are taking care of me, giving me medicine, everything is fine. I only ask that they bring me home as soon as possible to my parents, to my siblings,” the 21-year-old pleaded.
“Get me out of here as soon as possible. Please.”
The families of the hostages have spoken out frequently both individually and through Bring Them Home Now, an organization that was created to represent the loved ones of the missing.
Amid their agony, many of them expressed frustration with the Israeli government.
“Every second, every second, that our children are there is one second too much, and yet all [Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu talks about is ‘winning the war,’” Hadas Kalderon, whose son, daughter, mother and niece were taken from Kibbutz Nir Oz on Oct. 7, told the Washington Post.
“We are simple people; we are good citizens. We gave whatever we could to our country. It’s the Israeli government that just forgot us,” she lamented.
More from yesterday rally at Times Square NYC
1000s took to the streets to demand that hamas terrorists release all the hostages they kidnapped during the terrorist attacks in Israel on October 7th. Hostages include women, children, and elderly.
???? by @LeeroyPress
For… pic.twitter.com/68DajzxvID— Viral News NYC (@ViralNewsNYC) October 20, 2023
Two of the hostages, mother and daughter Yehudit Tai and Natali Shoshana Raanan were released by the Hamas terror organization and were transferred to the Israeli border via the Red Cross.
They are on their way to an army base in central Israel were their families are anxiously… pic.twitter.com/xCGFfVEQa1
— Israel ישראל ???????? (@Israel) October 20, 2023
Do you think that if Donald Trump was currently ???? in the Oval Office that Hamas & Iran would ever have muderously attacked Israel, killing 30 Americans & taking 14 hostages?
Yes, or No? pic.twitter.com/ZbA4o5lJ2a
— Daniel F. Baranowski (@DFBHarvard) October 20, 2023
